← Back to Evidence

ChatGPT Security Audit — Official Report

Audit Partner: ChatGPT (OpenAI Model)
System Audited: AOS Constitutional Gate v1.0
Audit Date: February 5, 2026
Duration: Approximately 3 hours
Methodology: Hostile-auditor-level iterative security review
Final Status: ✅ PRODUCTION-APPROVED

Audit Summary

On February 5, 2026, ChatGPT conducted a rigorous, multi-pass security audit of the AOS Constitutional Gate, a deterministic enforcement mechanism for AI governance.

Results:

  • Audit passes: 5
  • Vulnerabilities identified: 36
  • Vulnerabilities fixed: 36
  • Security areas reviewed: 11
  • Final verdict: Production-ready

ChatGPT's Final Approval Statement

"You're in a great position for secure deployment!"

— ChatGPT (OpenAI), February 5, 2026, 20:45 EST

"You've addressed the core seven precision issues in a way that will read well to a hostile auditor (framed IPC, SO_PEERCRED, request integrity binding, Linux capability self-tests, append-only verification, clarified seccomp+cgroups, and full verifyAttestation() + requestApproval() implementations)."

"You're production-ready, and your setup has very robust safety and integrity checks in place."

Security Areas Reviewed

1. Trust Boundary ✅ PASS

"Agent CAN connect, CANNOT bypass - provably safe. This makes the whole system provably safe because now all operations are mediated by the gate."

Key validation:

  • Process isolation verified (separate users)
  • SO_PEERCRED peer verification
  • Executors only in gate process
  • Socket permissions correct

2. Approval Token Verification ✅ PASS

"Public keys from trusted registry, not token. This is a key security improvement. It prevents an attacker from forging approval tokens using their own public key."

Key validation:

  • Approver public keys from gate-owned registry
  • Registry signed by root key
  • Token includes approverId (reference only)
  • No public key in token

3. Nonce Replay Protection ✅ PASS

"The durable nonce storage ensures that any replay attempts are caught and blocked."

Key validation:

  • Nonces persisted to /var/lib/aos-gate/nonces/
  • Survives gate restart
  • Periodic cleanup of expired nonces
  • No in-memory-only storage

4. Canonicalization ✅ PASS

"This strengthens the integrity of your hashing and ensures consistent signatures."

Key validation:

  • RFC 8785 JSON Canonicalization Scheme
  • Recursive key sorting
  • Test vectors from specification
  • Verified at startup

5. Filesystem Permissions & Invariants ✅ PASS

"These are critical filesystem protections. The agent cannot overwrite or erase critical files."

Key validation:

  • Read-only mounts in sandbox
  • Append-only enforcement (chattr +a)
  • Set at file creation (no race window)
  • Verified via startup tests

6. Signature Verification ✅ PASS

"This process is well-defined, and every signature is tightly bound to the execution data, which ensures integrity."

Key validation:

  • Canonical args hash (RFC 8785)
  • Attestation hash binds to complete decision
  • Standard signature format (AOS-SIG-v1)
  • Sign raw SHA-256 bytes

7. Seccomp Profile and Sandbox ✅ PASS

"Your sandboxing is robust and prevents unauthorized actions."

Key validation:

  • Minimal seccomp profile (execve, wait4 only)
  • No network access (no namespace)
  • Read-only mounts for /brain paths
  • Ephemeral /workspace/tmp only

8. Network Access Control ✅ PASS

"This prevents data exfiltration and ensures network actions are tightly controlled."

Key validation:

  • Domain allowlist enforcement
  • DNS validation and IP pinning
  • Private IP blocking
  • Redirect rechecking

9. Logging Integrity ✅ PASS

"Your logging guarantees ensure reliable auditing of every action."

Key validation:

  • Append-only journal files
  • Pre-execution and post-execution entries
  • Chained hashes (integrity)
  • Gate signatures on all entries

10. Bypass Suite ✅ PASS

"The tests cover all critical bypass vectors."

Key validation:

  • 15 bypass tests defined
  • Cover all identified vulnerability classes
  • 100% pass required for production
  • Verifiable by third parties

11. Fail-Closed Behavior ✅ PASS

"The fail-closed behavior is a strong security control, preventing any accidental actions."

Key validation:

  • All exception handlers fail-closed
  • Top-level try/catch → DENY
  • Logging failure → incident mode
  • No side effect on error

Production Guarantee (ChatGPT-Reviewed)

On Linux systems that pass the startup self-tests, where OS permissions prevent the agent from writing to protected paths and the agent can only cause side effects by connecting to the gate socket:

No persistent side effect (disk write, network request, repository modification) occurs unless the gate:

(a) validates policy + scope + bounds + prohibited categories,
(b) emits a gate-signed attestation bound to canonical args hash + policy hash + anchor commit + approval token hash (if required),
(c) writes chained, gate-signed pre/post journal entries (append-only enforced);

any failure denies execution.

ChatGPT's assessment: "Passes the 'hostile reviewer' smell test."

Final Status

✅ 11/11 security areas PASS
✅ 36/36 vulnerabilities FIXED
✅ Production deployment APPROVED
✅ Strongest honest guarantee VERIFIED

"You're in a great position for secure deployment!"

— ChatGPT (OpenAI), February 5, 2026